Comparing data for types of groups: "Atheist", "Freethinker", "Humanist", and "Different".

Membership

For "Atheist" groups, the median number of members is 107. For "Freethinker" groups, the median is 110. For "Humanist" groups, the median number of members falls at 55."Different" groups have a median number of members at 75.

Members by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

9

88.889

85.9061

28.6354

22.856

to 154.922

75.000

65.000

20.000

to 100.000

Atheist 

15

174.600

203.1572

52.4550

62.095

to 287.105

107.000

184.500

35.000

to 250.000

Freethinker 

15

146.067

121.7459

31.4347

78.646

to 213.487

110.000

125.000

40.000

to 230.000

Humanist 

14

95.357

100.6797

26.9078

37.226

to 153.488

55.000

63.750

30.000

to 120.000

Although the median numbers of members for "Atheist", "Freethinker", and "Other than Freethinker" groups fall slightly above the median for all groups, these group medians are still within the 95%CI range for all groups (48 to 115). "Humanist", "Different", and "Other than atheist" groups, though falling below the median for all groups, are still within the 95%CI range as well.

From the data available, there is insufficient evidence to suggest on the basis of membership that any particular label for groups is more effective than any other label.

Area in Square Miles

"Atheist" groups cover a median of 1300 square miles per group with a 95% CI of 300 to 20,100square miles.

"Freethinker" groups cover a median of 2650 square miles per group with a 95% CI of 300 to 11,300 square miles.

"Different" groups cover a median of 1300 square miles per group with a 95% CI of 300 to 7900 square miles.

"Humanist" groups cover a median of 1300 square miles per group with a 95% CI of 300 to 7900 square miles.

Area in Thousands of Square Miles by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

9

3.678

4.9641

1.6547

-0.138

to 7.493

1.300

4.300

0.300

to 7.900

Atheist 

13

10.128

16.9331

4.6964

-0.105

to 20.360

2.800

9.200

0.300

to 20.100

Freethinker 

14

6.807

9.7694

2.6110

1.166

to 12.448

2.650

7.200

0.300

to 11.300

Humanist 

14

8.029

23.8646

6.3781

-5.750

to 21.808

1.300

2.400

0.300

to 2.800

No groups fall below a 300 square mile area within the 95% confidence range.

"Atheist" groups tend to have the broadest area of coverage, with highest median and upper limit of CI, followed closely by "Freethinker" groups. The medians for "Different" and "Humanist" groups are the same, however, "Humanist" groups have the lowest upper limit of CI of all groups at 2800 square miles. "Humanist" groups seem to generally have a more concentrated area of focus. More on this later in the report.

 

 

Active Members

For all groups, the median for active members is about 23, with a 95%CI 15 to 30.

For "Atheist" groups 15, 95%CI 12 to 40 (n=9)

For "Freethinker" groups 25, 95%CI 9 to 30 (n=9)

For "Humanist" groups 25, 95%CI 15 to 60 (n=7)

For "Different" groups the median is 21, (n=4), and CI is the full range of data points.

Active by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

4

25.500

17.1561

8.5781

-1.799

to 52.799

21.000

25.500

-

to -

Atheist 

9

20.556

12.8852

4.2951

10.651

to 30.460

15.000

8.000

12.000

to 40.000

Freethinker 

9

31.000

27.2947

9.0982

10.019

to 51.981

25.000

7.000

9.000

to 30.000

Humanist 

7

30.143

15.0713

5.6964

16.204

to 44.081

25.000

12.500

15.000

to 60.000

While "Freethinker" and "Humanist" groups have higher medians than "Atheist" groups, the median for atheist groups still falls within the CI of the other two, though at the lower limit of the CI for "Humanist" groups. The upper limit of the CI for Atheist groups however is well within the range for both "Humanist" groups, and above the CI for "Freethinker". For this reason the data is insufficient to conclude that on the basis of active membership any group type is more effective than the others.

Ranking (excluding "Different") in descending order: "Humanist", "Freethinker" and "Atheist".

 

 

 

Percent Active

Regarding percentage of active members (n=29), the median is 25%, with a 95% CI of 17 to 33% of members actively participating.

For "Atheist" groups 17%, 95%CI 5 to 29% (n=9)

For "Freethinker" groups 30%, 95%CI 13 to 33% (n=9)

For "Humanist" groups 30%, 95%CI 6 to 75% (n=7)

For "Different" groups the median is 39.5% (n=4) and CI is the full range of data points.

%active by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

4

37.250

15.1740

7.5870

13.105

to 61.395

39.500

23.250

-

to -

Atheist 

9

17.556

10.3936

3.4645

9.566

to 25.545

17.000

15.000

5.000

to 29.000

Freethinker 

9

31.556

23.9171

7.9724

13.171

to 49.940

30.000

12.000

13.000

to 33.000

Humanist 

7

34.000

23.6573

8.9416

12.121

to 55.879

30.000

28.500

6.000

to 75.000

While "Freethinker" and "Humanist" groups have higher medians than "Atheist" groups, the median for "Atheist" groups still falls within the CI of the other two, though near the lower limit of the CI for "Freethinker" groups. The upper limit of the CI for "Atheist" groups however is well within the range for both "Freethinker" and "Humanist" groups. For this reason the data is insufficient to conclude that on the basis of percentage of active membership any group type is more effective than are others.

Ranking Excluding "Different" in descending order: "Humanist", "Freethinker", and "Atheist".

Average Distance Traveled

The median of average distance traveled by members to attend group functions is 10 miles, with 95% CI of 10 to 15 miles (n=49).

For "Atheist" groups 10, 95%CI 5 to 30 (n=13)

For "Freethinker" groups 15, 95%CI 10 to 30 (n=13)

For "Humanist" groups 10, 95%CI 8 to 20 (n=14)

For "Different" groups the median is 10, 95%CI 10 to 20 (n=9).

Distance by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

9

13.333

4.3301

1.4434

10.005

to 16.662

10.000

5.000

10.000

to 20.000

Atheist 

13

15.769

12.2213

3.3896

8.384

to 23.154

10.000

15.000

5.000

to 30.000

Freethinker 

13

19.462

11.6018

3.2178

12.451

to 26.472

15.000

10.000

10.000

to 30.000

Humanist 

14

14.643

8.8196

2.3571

9.551

to 19.735

10.000

6.250

8.000

to 20.000

Although the median for "Freethinker" groups is slightly higher than that of other groups, it is still within the CI’s of other groups, though at the upper limit of CI for All groups.

Also of note is that the upper limit of CI’s for "Humanist" and "Different" groups.

These points alone, however, do not indicate that one or more type groups elicit active members from farther away.

Meetings per Month

The median for group meetings for all groups is once per month (n=54), with 95%CI of 1 to 2 meetings per month.

For "Atheist" groups 1, 95%CI 1 to 4 (n=15)

For "Freethinker" groups 2, 95%CI 1 to 3 (n=15)

For "Humanist" groups 1, 95%CI 1 to 3 (n=14)

For "Different" groups the median is 1, 95%CI 1 to 3 (n=10).

Meetings/month by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

10

1.666

1.0893

0.3445

0.887

to 2.445

1.000

1.000

1.000

to 3.000

Atheist 

15

2.355

1.7707

0.4572

1.375

to 3.336

1.000

3.000

1.000

to 4.000

Freethinker 

15

2.267

1.4864

0.3838

1.444

to 3.090

2.000

2.000

1.000

to 3.000

Humanist 

14

1.595

1.0558

0.2822

0.985

to 2.205

1.000

1.000

1.000

to 3.000

For "Freethinker" groups, the median is higher, though the CI is comparable to other groups. For "Atheist" groups the upper limit of CI is higher, though the median is not.

While the CI is more likely to be affected by outliers (one or a few with values farther outside the ‘normal’ range), the median should not fluctuate as readily. The variable of "meetings per month" however, is trivial, and needs comparison with other variables to be of any use. More on this later in the report.

Fees

Although 52% of all groups do not charge membership fees (n=28), median fee amount for those who do (n=26) is $25/year, 95% CI $20 to $25/year.

For "Atheist" groups 66% do not charge a fee (n=12). 33% charge a fee (n=5).

Of atheist groups that charge a fee, the median fee is $24 per year, with a 95%CI of

$20 to $25 per year.

For "Freethinker" groups 66% do not charge a fee (n=12). 33% charge a fee (n=5).

Of atheist groups that charge a fee, the median fee is $24 per year, with a 95%CI of

$20 to $25 per year.

For "Humanist" 14% do not charge a fee (n=2). 86% charge a fee (n=12).

Of "Humanist" groups that charge a fee, the median fee is $25 per year, with a 95%CI of

$20 to $30 per year.

For "Different" groups 60% do not charge a fee (n=6). 40% charge a fee (n=4).

Of "Different" groups that charge a fee, the median fee is $30 per year

Fees/amount by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

4

30.000

12.9099

6.4550

9.457

to 50.543

30.000

20.000

-

to -

Atheist 

5

22.800

2.5884

1.1576

19.586

to 26.014

24.000

5.000

-

to -

Freethinker 

5

22.800

2.5884

1.1576

19.586

to 26.014

24.000

5.000

-

to -

Humanist 

12

24.667

7.4995

2.1649

19.902

to 29.432

25.000

10.000

20.000

to 30.000

The greatest significance from the data discovered through this comparison, is that the majority of "Humanist" groups charge a membership fee. There may be a relationship between this (charging a fee), and lower overall membership.

Overall Satisfaction

Respondents were asked to rate their over-all satisfaction with their group (with 1 being completely miserable and 10 being ecstatic). The median response to this question was "8", with 95% CI of "8" being accurate itself (n=51).

For "Atheist" groups median 7.5, 95%CI 5 to 9 (n=14)

For "Freethinker" groups median 9, 95%CI 8 to 10 (n=15)

For "Humanist" groups median 8, 95%CI 7 to 8 (n=13)

For "Different" groups the median is 8, 95%CI 7 to 9 (n=9).

Overall by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

9

8.000

1.4142

0.4714

6.913

to 9.087

8.000

1.000

7.000

to 9.000

Atheist 

14

7.214

1.5777

0.4216

6.303

to 8.125

7.500

2.250

5.000

to 9.000

Freethinker 

15

8.333

1.8772

0.4847

7.294

to 9.373

9.000

1.500

8.000

to 10.000

Humanist 

13

7.462

1.4500

0.4022

6.585

to 8.338

8.000

1.000

7.000

to 8.000

"Atheist" groups median ranks lowest. CI upper limit falls above "humanist" upper limit, at the upper margin of "Different" upper limit, and within that of "Freethinker"

"Freethinker" groups’ median ranks highest, with CI upper limit above all others, and Lower limit above "Humanist".

"Humanist" median is above "Atheist", below "Freethinker", and equal to "Different", with CI upper limit falling below lower limit of "Freethinker", and within the other two CI’s.

"Different" groups median rank above "Atheist", below "Freethinker", and equal to "Humanist" groups median, with CI upper limit passing above "Humanist" upper limit.

So….

Ranking in descending order of reported satisfaction: "Freethinker", "Different", "Humanist", and "Atheist".

Does this mean anything? Possibly…

Once again, more on this later in the report.

Scale Items Comparison by Group Type

Respondents were asked to rate, according to the importance to their groups, four items on a 1-10 scale (where "1" was least important and "10" was most important). The items are "Local Activism", "National Activism", "Education", and "Social".

Local Activism

For "Local Activism", the median response for all groups was "7.5", with 95% CI between "5" and "8" (n=50).

For "Atheist" groups median 6.5, 95%CI 1 to 10 (n=14)

For "Freethinker" groups median 7, 95%CI 1 to 9 (n=14)

For "Humanist" groups median 7.5, 95%CI 4 to 8 (n=14)

For "Different" groups the median is 8, 95%CI 1 to 9 (n=8).

LocAct by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

8

5.625

3.5832

1.2669

2.629

to 8.621

8.000

6.250

1.000

to 9.000

Atheist 

14

6.071

3.7306

0.9971

3.917

to 8.225

6.500

6.250

1.000

to 10.000

Freethinker 

14

5.857

3.3249

0.8886

3.937

to 7.777

7.000

4.750

1.000

to 9.000

Humanist 

14

6.500

2.3778

0.6355

5.127

to 7.873

7.500

3.000

4.000

to 8.000

 

"Atheist" groups median falls lowest at 6.5, and "Different" groups falls highest at 8, followed by

Ranking in descending order of reported satisfaction: "Freethinker", "Different", "Humanist", and "Atheist".

National Activism

For "National Activism", the median response for all groups was "3.5", with 95% CI between "2" and "5" (n=48).

For "Atheist" groups, the median 5.5, 95%CI 1 to 7 (n=14)

For "Freethinker" groups median 3, 95%CI 1 to 6 (n=14)

For "Humanist" groups median 3.5, 95%CI 1 to 8 (n=12)

For "Different" groups the median is 4.5, 95%CI 1 to 7 (n=8).

Nat Act by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

8

3.875

2.2952

0.8115

1.956

to 5.794

4.500

4.000

1.000

to 7.000

Atheist 

14

4.643

2.7903

0.7457

3.032

to 6.254

5.500

4.250

1.000

to 7.000

Freethinker 

14

3.857

2.9576

0.7904

2.149

to 5.565

3.000

4.000

1.000

to 6.000

Humanist 

12

4.167

3.3800

0.9757

2.019

to 6.314

3.000

5.500

1.000

to 8.000

"Atheist" groups median falls highest at 5.5, and "Different" groups falls next highest at 4.5, followed by "Humanist" groups, and "Freethinker".

Of not, the "Humanist" groups though having median below "Atheist" and "Different" has the highest upper limit for CI, which makes ranking for this group in this section a bit more ambiguous. "Freethinker" groups, however rank lowest by median and CI.

 

Education

For "Education", the median response was "8", with 95%CI matching that median at "8" as well (n=51).

For "Atheist" groups the median was 6, 95%CI 3 to 8 (n=14)

For "Freethinker" groups median 8, 95%CI 7 to 10 (n=14)

For "Humanist" groups median 8, 95%CI 8 to 10 (n=14)

For "Different" groups the median is 8, 95%CI 5 to 10 (n=9).

Education by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

9

8.111

1.9650

0.6550

6.601

to 9.622

8.000

2.000

5.000

to 10.000

Atheist 

14

5.786

2.6364

0.7046

4.264

to 7.308

6.000

3.000

3.000

to 8.000

Freethinker 

14

8.071

1.5915

0.4254

7.153

to 8.990

8.000

1.750

7.000

to 10.000

Humanist 

14

8.286

2.0913

0.5589

7.078

to 9.493

8.000

2.000

8.000

to 10.000

"Atheist" groups median falls lowest at 6, also with the lowest range for CI, with upper limit for CI falling at the lower end of CI for "Humanist" groups and near the lower limit of CI for "Freethinker" groups.

Ranking in descending order of importance of Education: "Humanist", "Freethinker", "Different", and "Atheist".

Social

For "Social", the median response was 9, with 95%CI of between 8 and 10 (n=50).

For "Atheist" groups the median was 9, 95%CI 6 to 10 (n=14)

For "Freethinker" groups median 9.5, 95%CI 8 to 10 (n=14)

For "Humanist" groups median 8.5, 95%CI 6 to 10 (n=14)

For "Different" groups the median is 9.5, 95%CI 6 to 10 (n=9).

Social by Type of Group 

n

Mean

SD

SE

95% CI of Mean

Median

IQR

95% CI of Median

Different 

8

9.125

1.3562

0.4795

7.991

to 10.259

9.500

1.000

6.000

to 10.000

Atheist 

14

8.000

2.5720

0.6874

6.515

to 9.485

9.000

3.500

6.000

to 10.000

Freethinker 

14

9.214

0.8926

0.2386

8.699

to 9.730

9.500

1.750

8.000

to 10.000

Humanist 

14

8.000

2.3534

0.6290

6.641

to 9.359

8.500

2.750

6.000

to 10.000

"Humanist" groups median falls lowest at 8.5, but with CI equal to all other groups save "Freethinker". "Freethinker", and "Different" groups have the highest medians at 9.5 with CI for "Freethinker" groups showing the highest lower limit at 8 to 10.

Ranking in descending order of importance of Social: "Freethinker", "Different", "Atheist" and "Humanist".

Advertising by Type of Group

"Atheist" groups use of advertising: Web-Site 60%, Print 40%, Word of Mouth 47%, Public

Act 33%, Fliers 27%, Newsletter 7%, E-Mail 7%, Radio 13%, Other 20%, TV 13%, Mailings 0%, Affiliations 0%, Business Cards 13%. Median number of types of advertising 3, 95%CI 2 to 4

"Freethinker" groups use of advertising Web-Site 60%, Print 67%, Word of Mouth 33%, Public

Act 27%, Fliers 20%, Newsletter 20%, E-Mail 13%, Radio 13%, Other 0%, TV 7%, Mailings 7%, Affiliations 0%, Business Cards 0%. Median number of types of advertising 3, 95%CI 2 to 3

"Humanist" groups use of advertising Web-Site 64%, Print 57%, Word of Mouth 14%, Public

Act 29%, Fliers 29%, Newsletter 29%, E-Mail 21%, Radio 7%, Other 14%, TV 0%, Mailings14%, Affiliations14%, Business Cards 0%. Median number of types of advertising 3, 95%CI 2 to 4

"Different" groups use of advertising Web-Site 60%, Print 20%, Word of Mouth 20%, Public

Act 20%, Fliers 20%, Newsletter 10%, E-Mail 30%, Radio 10%, Other 0%, TV 10%, Mailings 0%, Affiliations 0%, Business Cards 0%. Median number of types of advertising 2, 95%CI 1 to 3

"Atheist" groups rank higher than all other groups in their use of "Word of Mouth", "Public Activities", "Other", "TV", and "Business Cards" for advertising. "Atheist" groups rank lower than all other groups in the use of "Print", "Newsletter", and "E-mail".

"Freethinker" groups rank higher than all other groups in the use of "Print" media for advertising. "Freethinker groups" do not rank lower than all other groups in the use of any type of advertising.

"Humanist" groups rank higher than all other groups in their use of "Web-site", "Fliers", "Newsletter", "Mailings", and "Affiliations". "Humanist’ groups rank lower than all other groups in the use of "Word of Mouth", "Radio", and "TV"

"Different" groups rank higher than all other groups in their use of "E-mail" for advertising purposes. "Different" groups rank lower than all other groups in the use of "Public Activities", and in median number of different types of advertising.

The much awaited "Later in the report"

"Freethinker"

"Freethinker " groups ranked highest in overall membership, average distance traveled by members to attend functions, number of meetings per month, overall satisfaction, ranking social activities as important to the group, and in use of print media for advertising

"Freethinker" groups ranked lowest on National activism for importance to their group.

"Humanist"

"Humanist" groups ranked highest in number of active members, percent active members, charging of membership fees, educational activities as being important in group activities, and use of: "Web-site", "Fliers", "Newsletter", "Mailings", and "Affiliations" for advertisement.

"Humanist" groups ranked lowest in Area in Square miles, overall membership, average distance traveled to attend meetings, ranking of the importance of social activities to the group, and use of: "Word of Mouth" and "Radio" in advertising.

"Different"

"Different" groups ranked highest in the importance of local activism in group activities, and in the use of E-mail for advertisement.

"Different" groups ranked lowest in the use of public activities for advertisement and in number of types of advertisement.

 

"Atheist"

"Atheist" groups ranked highest in Are in Square miles, the use of "Word of Mouth", "Public Activities", TV, Business Cards, and "Other" forms of advertising.

"Atheist" groups ranked lowest in overall satisfaction, reporting of local activism and of educational activities as important for group activities, the use of Print media, newsletters, and email for advertising.

 

NEXT ---->